Skip to content
ForgeCRO Book a call

Industry index · United States

Coffee AI Visibility Index

30 questions that American coffee shoppers put to AI assistants, each asked on ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini. 84 answers later, these are the brands they recommend and the ones they leave out. Window dated 13 September 2026.

Get the full reportJump to the leaderboard

  • ChatGPT
  • Perplexity
  • Gemini
Answers
84
Ranked brands
34
Never named
12
Category average
11.1

The leaderboard

Every brand, scored on the same questions.

Visibility is the share of answers that named the brand. Average position is where it appeared when named. Movement is against the previous window.

Coffee leaderboard, 13 September 2026
RankBrandVisibilityAvg posMoveBy platform
1Counter Culture52.43.2new
2Stumptown47.63.2new
3Onyx Coffee Lab46.43.4new
4Peet's Coffee34.53.8new
5Intelligentsia34.54.1new
6Verve31.05.9new
7Kicking Horse19.06.8new
8Sey Coffee14.34.0new
9George Howell14.36.0new
10La Colombe14.36.5new
11Death Wish Coffee11.96.4new
12Equator Coffees10.78.8new
13Passenger Coffee9.55.3new
14Lifeboost7.11.3new
15Volcanica7.13.7new
16Atlas Coffee Club7.13.8new
17Four Sigmatic4.81.5new
18Cometeer4.86.3new
19Black Rifle Coffee2.45.0new
20Chamberlain Coffee2.48.0new
21Olympia Coffee1.25.0new
22Sightglass1.211.0new
23Bulletproof0.0—new
24Caffè Umbria0.0—new
25Climpson & Sons0.0—new
26Devoción0.0—new
27Happy Mug0.0—new
28Methodical Coffee0.0—new
29Partners Coffee0.0—new
30Podium Coffee Club0.0—new
31PT’s0.0—new
32Ruby Coffee Roasters0.0—new
33Savorista0.0—new
34Square Mile Coffee Roasters0.0—new

Named, but not on Shopify

Café Bustelo (15.5), Heart Coffee Roasters (8.3), Mount Hagen Organic (2.4). Listed so nothing is hidden; not ranked, because the Shortlist scores Shopify stores.

Gemini search grounding

Gemini ran a live web search on 4 of its 30 answers in this window; the rest came from what the model already knew. ChatGPT and Perplexity are asked with search on for every question.

Not yet verified

Blue Bottle, Javy, Lavazza, Dunkin’, Equal Exchange, Illy, Nescafé Gold, Trade, Driftaway Coffee could not be reached to confirm the platform and are held out of the ranking until they can.

The full Coffee report

Every question, and who won it.

Free, and it opens as soon as you send the form. Built from the same scan window as the leaderboard above.

Free report

Opens straight away

Free. The report opens in this tab. Work email only; personal and disposable addresses are turned away.

  • All 30 shopper questions, with the brands named on each
  • The leader on each assistant
  • Every brand that was never named
  • The full leaderboard, all 34 brands

What the data shows

Three findings from this window.

Drawn from the 84 answers behind the leaderboard, measured against 34 US coffee stores on Shopify.

Zero mentions

12of 34

Left out of every answer.

None of the 84 answers mentioned Bulletproof, Caffè Umbria, Climpson & Sons, Devoción, Happy Mug, Methodical Coffee, Partners Coffee, Podium Coffee Club, PT’s, Ruby Coffee Roasters, Savorista, Square Mile Coffee Roasters.

Top three

Counter Culture is out in front.

It turned up in 44 of 84 answers and on 22 of 30 questions, typically around position 3.2, for a score of 52.4. Next is Stumptown on 47.6, 4.8 behind.

  1. 1Counter Culture52.4
  2. 2Stumptown47.6
  3. 3Onyx Coffee Lab46.4

Platform split

Intelligentsia swings 44.2 points.

One brand, one set of questions, one window, and a very different score on each assistant.

ChatGPT54.2
Perplexity43.3
Gemini10.0

Common questions

About the Coffee index.

Which coffee brand gets recommended by AI most often?

Counter Culture tops the US Coffee index in this window: 44 of 84 answers mentioned it, a score of 52.4.

How many coffee brands does the Shortlist measure?

34 American coffee brands with confirmed Shopify stores, in the window dated 13 September 2026. A further 3 brands were named but are not on Shopify, so they are listed and not ranked.

What does the Coffee score measure?

Each of the 30 shopper questions went to all three assistants in the window dated 13 September 2026, which produced 84 usable answers. A brand’s score is the percentage of those answers that mention it.

Is the method published?

Yes. How the questions are chosen, when scans run, the Shopify check, the locked brand list and the scoring rule are all written up on the methodology page.

Your store on this board

See why the Coffee leaders get picked, and what your store lacks.

The free AI visibility audit reads your store the way the assistants do and lists what is missing, most important first.

Book a callRun the free audit